Comparative Test of 3mm Stainless Steel Welding Performance between The Raycus 1200W And RECI 1200W Lasers

Views: 83 Author: Site Editor Publish Time: 2025-09-08 Origin: Site

Inquire

1. Introduction

2. Test Purpose

3. Test Equipment and Parameters

4. Test Method

5. Results Analysis

6. Conclusion

Introduction

Laser welding technology is becoming increasingly important in the manufacturing industry. Its ability to provide high-precision and efficient welding solutions has led to its widespread application in the automotive, aerospace, electronics, and other fields. With technological advancements, more and more companies are focusing on the performance of laser welding equipment to improve production efficiency and weld quality.

This article compares the actual performance of the Raycus 1200W and RECI 1200W laser welding machines in welding 3mm stainless steel. Through detailed testing and analysis, this article explores the differences between the two laser welding machines in terms of welding speed, weld quality, and ease of use, providing industry professionals with a reference for selecting appropriate laser welding equipment.

Test Purpose

The primary purpose of this test was to evaluate the performance differences between Raycus and RECI laser welders under identical power conditions. Specific objectives included:

1. Weld Quality: Comparing the weld appearance, uniformity, and strength of the two laser welders.

2. Welding Speed: Measuring the time required for each machine to weld the same material and thickness under identical power conditions to assess efficiency.

2. Weld Penetration: Examining the penetration and reliability of the two machines when welding the same thickness.

Through this evaluation, we aim to provide users with detailed comparative data on Raycus and RECI laser welders under identical power conditions, helping industry professionals make more informed equipment choices.

Test Equipment and Parameters

A. Raycus 1200W Laser

1. Power: 1200W

2. Material: 3mm stainless steel

3. Wire Feed Speed: 15cm/min

4. Welding Results: The welding speed was slow, but the weld quality was acceptable and penetration was achieved. The weld appearance was uniform, but the weld time was long.

B. RECI 1200W Laser

1. Power: 1200W

2. Material: 3mm stainless steel

3. Wire Feed Speed: 40cm/min

4. Welding Results: The welding process was easy and fast, with excellent weld quality and penetration. The weld appearance was smooth and uniform, and production efficiency was significantly improved.

By comparing the test parameters of the two lasers, we can more comprehensively analyze the performance differences when welding the same materials. Click here for more information

Test Method

This test aimed to evaluate the performance differences between the Raycus 1200W and RECI 1200W laser welders when welding 3mm stainless steel. The test was conducted according to the following steps:

1. Test Preparation

Environmental Conditions: The test was conducted in an environment with a temperature of 30°C and a humidity of 50% to ensure that the welding results were not affected by environmental factors.

Equipment Setup: The parameters for both laser welders were set, including power, welding speed, and wire feed speed.

2. Material Preparation

3mm stainless steel sheets of the same specifications were used to ensure consistency and prevent material differences from affecting the test results.

3. Welding Procedure

Welding Operation: Each welder performed continuous welds, with each weld length set to 8cm.

Welding Speed: Welding was performed at the set wire feed speed, ensuring that both machines welded in the same position.

Through this systematic approach, we hoped to comprehensively evaluate the performance differences between the Raycus and RECI laser welders when welding 3mm stainless steel, providing reliable data support for subsequent analysis and conclusions. Click here for more information

Results Analysis

A. Welding Speed

Raycus Welding Machine: In this test, the Raycus 1200W laser welder demonstrated lower welding efficiency, requiring more time to complete a 8cm weld. Specifically, its wire feed speed was set to 15cm/min, which compromised productivity and made it suitable for applications requiring lower welding speeds.

Comparative test of 3mm stainless steel welding performance between the Raycus 1200W and RECI 1200W lasers samples-Suntop

Comparative test of 3mm stainless steel welding performance between the Raycus 1200W and RECI 1200W lasers sample-Suntop

RECI Welding Machine: In comparison, the RECI 1200W laser welder achieved significantly faster welding speeds under the same conditions, reaching a wire feed speed of 40cm/min. The RECI welder can complete welds more quickly, improving overall productivity and making it suitable for production lines requiring efficient welding.

Comparative test of 3mm stainless steel welding performance between the Raycus 1200W and RECI 1200W lasers samples

Comparative test of 3mm stainless steel welding performance between the Raycus 1200W and RECI 1200W lasers sample

B. Welding Quality

Weld Appearance: Visual inspection revealed that both welds produced excellent weld appearance, with smooth welds free of noticeable defects, meeting industry standards. The Raycus weld produced relatively uniform weld widths, but the slower welding speed may have resulted in localized overheating and slight variations in weld color.

Weld strength: Tensile and pressure tests were conducted to evaluate weld strength. Both welders produced welds capable of withstanding the pressures commonly encountered in industrial applications, demonstrating excellent overall strength and meeting design requirements.

Weldability: Both lasers successfully achieved full penetration. Cross-sectional observations of the welds revealed uniform penetration, effectively ensuring a secure connection.

Despite differences in welding speed, the Raycus and RECI welders both offer excellent weld quality, making them suitable for the diverse needs and applications of stainless steel welding. Click here for more information

Conclusion

A comparative test of the Raycus 1200W and RECI 1200W laser welders in welding 3mm stainless steel yields the following conclusions:

1. Welding Speed:

The Raycus 1200W laser welder has a relatively slow welding speed, with a wire feed speed of only 15cm/min, which affects overall production efficiency. It is suitable for small batches or applications with low welding speed requirements.

The RECI 1200W laser welder offers superior speed, with a wire feed speed of 40cm/min. It can efficiently complete welding tasks and significantly improve production efficiency, making it more suitable for large-scale production or processes requiring higher welding speeds.

2. Weld Quality:

Both welders demonstrated excellent performance in terms of weld appearance, strength, and weld penetration. The welds were uniform and beautiful, with excellent penetration, meeting industry standards and suitable for practical applications.

Based on the above performance differences, we offer the following recommendations:

If you prioritize welding efficiency and production speed and need to perform large-volume welding operations, the RECI1200W laser welder is the superior choice, as it can complete more welds in a shorter time, significantly improving production line efficiency.

If your application does not require high welding speed, such as small batches or specialized welding processes, the Raycus 1200W laser welder can also meet your requirements and may be more cost-effective.

In short, choosing the right laser welding equipment based on your specific production needs and budget will help improve the efficiency and quality of your welding operations.